Conflicting viewpoint relational database querying: an argumentation approach

International audienceWithin the framework of the European project EcoBioCap, we model a real world use case aiming at conceiving the next generation of food packagings. The objective is to select packaging materials according to possibly conflicting requirements expressed by the involved parties (food and packaging industries, health authorities, consumers, waste management authority, etc.). The requirements and user preferences are modeled by several ontological rules provided by the stakeholders expressing their viewpoints and expertise. Since several aspects need to be considered (CO2 and O2 permeance, interaction with the product, sanitary, cost, end of life, etc.) in order to select objects, an argumentation process can be used to express/reason about different aspects or criteria describing the packagings. We define then in this paper an argumentation approach which combines a description logic (DLR-Lite) within ASPIC framework for relational database querying. The argumentation step is finally used to express and/or enrich a bipolar query employed for packaging selection

Data reliability assessment in a data warehouse opened on the Web

International audienceThis paper presents an ontology-driven workflow that feeds and queries a data warehouse opened on the Web. Data are extracted from data tables in Web documents. As web documents are very heterogeneous in nature, a key issue in this workflow is the ability to assess the reliability of retrieved data. We first recall the main steps of our method to annotate and query Web data tables driven by a domain ontology. Then we propose an original method to assess Web data table reliability from a set of criteria by the means of evidence theory. Finally, we show how we extend the workflow to integrate the reliability assessment step

Application informatique : le logiciel CARAT

De nombreux logiciels proposent des outils de calcul d’exposition et fournissent desestimateurs et des graphiques décrivant la distribution de l’exposition. Citons par exemple leprojet MONTE CARLO financé par le programme Qualité de vie et ressources vivantes(Living Resources) du programme Santé, Alimentation et Nutrition du 5ème programmecadre de la commission européenne (http://montecarlo.tchpc.tcd.ie/, Gibney and van der Voet,2003)

Enriching queries using argumentation: an industrial application of argumentation

DemonstrationInternational audienceWithin the framework of the European project EcoBioCap (ECOefficient BIOdegradable Composite Advanced Packaging), aiming at conceiving the next generation of food packagings, we introduce an argumentation-based tool for management of conflicting viewpoints between preferences expressed by the involved parties (food and packaging industries, health and waste management etc.). The requirements and user preferences are modeled by several ontological rules provided by the stakeholders expressing their viewpoints and expertise. The argumentation tool implements the process which has been introduced in previous work [10,11] combining a description logic (DLR-Lite) within ASPIC framework for relational database querying purposes. In this paper, we recall briefly the principles underlying the reasoning process, and we detail the main functional- ities and the architecture of the argumentation tool covering the overall reasoning steps starting from formal representation of text arguments and ending by extraction of justified preferences. Finally, we detail its operational functioning through a real life case study to determine the justifiable choices between recyclable, com- postable and biodegradable packaging materials based on stakeholders’ arguments

Units of measure identification in unstructured scientific documents in microbial risk in food

International audienceOBJECTIVE(S) A preliminary step in microbial risk assessment in food is to gather and capitalize experimental data. Data capitalization is a crucial stake in an overall decision support system which consists of predicting microbial behavior [1]. In the framework of the French ANR project MAP'OPT (Equilibrium Gas Composition in Modified Atmosphere Packaging and Food Quality), the predictive modeling platform Sym'Previus (www.symprevius.org) should be able to propose a global approach to establish a scientifically sound method for choosing an appropriate modified atmosphere and associated packaging solution. Our work is part of this overall system and aims at extracting semi-automatically experimental data from unstructured scientific documents. Indeed, these documents use natural language combined with domain-specific terminology that is extremely time-consuming and tedious to extract in the free form of text and therefore to gather and capitalize. Our work relies on the MAP'OPT-Onto ontology [4], which has been built as an extension of the ontology used in Sym'Previus by adding concepts about food packaging, quantity concepts and concepts managing units of measures. Experimental data are often expressed with concepts (e.g packaging, permeability) or a numerical value often followed with its unit of measure (e.g. 258 amol m-1 s-1 Pa-1). In this paper, our work deals with unit recognition, known as a scientific challenge. METHOD(S) Extracting automatically quantitative data is a painstaking process because units suffer from different ways of writing within documents. We can encounter same units written in different manners such as amol m-1 s-1 Pa-1 written as amol.m-1 .s-1 .Pa-1 or as amol/m/s/Pa. We aim at focusing on the extraction and identification of these variant units seen as synonyms, in order to enrich iteratively an ontology, which represents a predefined vocabulary used to annotate, capitalize and query experimental data extracted from texts [2]. Our work addresses unit extraction and identification issues from texts to enrich an ontology in a two-step approach. First, we use text-mining methods and supervised learning approaches in order to predict relevant parts of the text where synonyms of units or new units are. The second step of our method consists in extracting specific strings representing units in the segments of texts found in the previous step. The extracted candidates are compared to units already present in the ontology using a new edit measure based on Damerau-Levenshtein [3]. RESULTS We have made experiments on 115 scientific documents (i.e. around 35 000 sentences) on food packaging. Each unit is recognized from a list of 211 units already defined in the MAP'OPT-Onto. Our learning algorithms predict that almost 5 000 sentences contain units. This prediction is correct for 95,5% of cases. In the second step, we have successfully extracted 38 terms as either synonyms or new units from sentences selected in the first step. So, we can propose 18% of enrichment of the pre-existing MAP'OPT-Onto

A Food Packaging Use Case for Argumentation

International audienceWithin the framework of the European project EcoBioCap (ECOefficient BIOdegradable Composite Advanced Packaging), aiming at conceiving the next generation of food packagings, we introduce an argumentation-based tool for management of conflicting viewpoints between preferences expressed by the involved parties (food and packaging industries, health and waste management authorities, consumers, etc.). In this paper we recall briefly the principles underlying the reasoning process, and we detail the main functionalities and the architecture of the argumentation tool covering the overall reasoning steps starting from formal representation of text arguments and ending by extraction of justified preferences. Finally, we detail its operational functioning through a real life case study to determine the justifiable choices between recyclable, compostable and biodegradable packaging materials based on stakeholders’ arguments

Identification des unités de mesure dans les textes scientifiques

National audienceIdentification of units of measures in scientific texts. The work presented in this paper consists in identifying specialized terms (units of measures) in textual documents in order to enrich a onto-terminological resource (OTR). The first step permits to predict the localization of unit of measure variants in the documents. We have used a method based on supervised learning. This method permits to reduce significantly the variant search space staying in an optimal search context (reduction of 86% of the search space on the studied set of documents). The second step uses a new similarity measure identifying automatically variants associated with term denoting a unit of measure already present in the OTR with a precision rate of 82% for a threshold above 0.6 on the studied corpus.Le travail présenté dans cet article se situe dans le cadre de l'identification de termes spécialisés (unités de mesure) à partir de données textuelles pour enrichir une Ressource Termino-Ontologique (RTO). La première étape de notre méthode consiste à prédire la localisation des variants d'unités de mesure dans les documents. Nous avons utilisé une méthode reposant sur l'apprentissage supervisé. Cette méthode permet de réduire sensiblement l'espace de recherche des variants tout en restant dans un contexte optimal de recherche (réduction de 86% de l'espace de recherché sur le corpus étudié). La deuxième étape du processus, une fois l'espace de recherche réduit aux variants d'unités, utilise une nouvelle mesure de similarité permettant d'identifier automatiquement les variants découverts par rapport à un terme d'unité déjà référencé dans la RTO avec un taux de précision de 82% pour un seuil au dessus de 0.6 sur le corpus étudié

Ontology Evolution for Experimental Data in Food

International audienceThroughout its life cycle, an ontology may change in order to adapt to domain changes or to new usages. This paper presents an ontology evolution activity [1] applied to an ontology dedicated to the annotation of experimental data in food [2], and a plug-in, DynarOnto, which assists ontology engineers for carrying out the ontology changes. Our evolution method is an a priori method which takes as input an ontology in a consistent state, implements the changes selected to be applied and manages all the consequences of those changes by producing an ontology in a consistent state

Extraction de relations n-aires interphrastiques guidée par une RTO

National audienceNous proposons dans cet article une méthode d'extraction d'instances de relations naires dans un texte guidée par une Ressource Termino-Ontologique (RTO) de domaine. Une RTO est une ressource comportant une composante conceptuelle (l'ontologie) et une composante terminologique (la terminologie), dans laquelle les termes sont distingués des concepts qu'ils dénotent. L'ontologie permet la modélisation de relations n-aires, reliant des arguments pouvant être des concepts symboliques et des quantités. La méthode proposée s'applique aux relations n-aires formulées de façon implicite dans le texte et dont les instances d'arguments peuvent être exprimées à travers différentes phrases du texte. ABSTRACT. We propose in this paper a method to extract instances of n-ary relations in a text guided by an Ontological and Terminological Resource (OTR). An OTR is a resource composed of a conceptual component (the ontology) and a terminological component (the terminology) in which the terms are distinguished from the concepts they denote. The ontology allows n-ary relationships to be described between arguments which can be symbolic concepts and quantities. The method is dedicated to the extraction of n-ary relations which are implicit in the text and whose instances of arguments may be expressed in different sentences of the text

Alignement d'ontologies : exploitation des ontologies liées sur le web de données

International audienceNous proposons dans cet article une méthode d’alignement d’une ontologie source avec des ontologies cibles déjà publiées et liées sur le web de données. Nous présentons ensuite un retour d’expérience sur l’alignement d’une ontologie dans le domaine des sciences du vivant et de l’environnement avec AGROVOC et NALT